Gabriella Gains of Gato Dates: “I’d Love to Take Some of the Guilt Out of Indulgence” – On Farmers Markets, Community and Building a Modern Date Brand

Gabriella Gains is an entrepreneur and cofounder of Gato, a premium date confectionery brand. Inspired by her personal food journey, she helped develop a range of indulgent treats featuring quality ingredients. Alongside cofounder Tonya, she is building Gato through thoughtful sourcing, distinctive branding, community engagement, and international expansion.

The Capitalyst: You’ve said Gato came from a very personal desire to make indulgence feel good again. At what point did this shift from being a personal solution into a business you knew could scale?

Gabriella Gains: I started making the original Gato date in 2021, while navigating years of gut and hormonal issues and making changes to my diet and lifestyle. I’d been advised to eat paleo, but I didn’t want that to mean giving up the delicious, joyful part of food. Our cashew butter and walnut date was my solution.

A friend (Tonya) tried one at a dinner party, fell in love, and told me I needed to package and sell them. It took until February 2024 for us to actually do it. We launched at Melrose Place Farmers Market in LA, sold out within three hours, and made $1,500.

That first year was about proving the concept. We were building in our spare time, getting immediate feedback, and watching customers return every weekend. Moving production out of my kitchen and into a commercial kitchen made it feel like a real business. But December 2024 was the turning point: we had enough evidence of repeat demand to commit to Gato full-time and believe it could grow beyond the markets.

The Capitalyst: Many founders talk about identifying a market gap, but you seem to have started with a deeply lived problem. How did your own health journey shape the product, ingredients, and emotional tone of the brand?

Gabriella Gains: I never looked at the date category and thought, “There’s a business opportunity.” I was trying to make something I wanted to eat. At the time, I needed ingredients that fit the way I was eating, but flavor mattered just as much. Food has always been a source of joy for me. Too often, the options I found felt like a choice between something that met my ingredient standards and something that actually tasted indulgent. I wanted both.

That shaped everything: our juicy Medjool dates, single-ingredient nut butters, dark chocolate, and the care we put into sourcing. Our core range is certified organic, vegan, gluten-free, and made without refined sugar. Some collaborations have different ingredients and dietary profiles, which we communicate separately.

The relationships behind those ingredients matter, too. We know our date farmers, work with small-batch nut butter producers, and source from family-owned businesses, including our cacao supplier. Emotionally, I wanted Gato to feel generous and joyful. We lead with flavor and the pleasure of eating something delicious. The ingredient standards are fundamental to the product, but they don’t have to dominate the conversation.

The Capitalyst: Gato sits between wellness, confectionery, gifting, and luxury. How did you decide where the brand should live, and what did you deliberately choose not to be?

Gabriella Gains: Our customers helped us understand that. We arrived at farmers markets thinking we were selling dessert. Then people told us they were having a date with their morning coffee, before or after a workout, as a four o’clock pick-me-up, and after dinner. We realized Gato could fit into several moments throughout someone’s day.

The gifting side was equally organic. Our early packaging was a kraft box ordered from Amazon with a sticker on top, and people were still taking it to birthdays, baby showers, and dinner parties. That told us the product already felt special enough to give someone. We built packaging formats that made gifting easier.

We deliberately chose not to make Gato exclusively a wellness snack or reserve it for special occasions. We want the quality and presentation of a premium treat, with ways to enjoy it every day. That’s why formats matter. A gift box serves one occasion; a single-serve pouch creates an accessible first purchase or an easy grab-and-go treat. The experience should feel unmistakably Gato across all of them.

The Capitalyst: Gato has resonated with a community that sees it as more than a snack. Why do you think the brand has created such emotional loyalty, and what role has storytelling played?

Gabriella Gains: The relationships came first. LA farmers markets are incredibly community-driven. You see the same faces every weekend, learn people’s names, and hear about their lives. Customers get to know who is making their food and why. Some of those early customers became our biggest champions. They shared Gato with friends, gave it as gifts, and introduced us to retailers. They wanted their local stores to stock us because they wanted easier access to the product. That kind of support is very personal.

As we grew, sharing more of ourselves online helped extend that relationship beyond the market booth. We started showing what building Gato actually looks like: the exciting launches, the manufacturing challenges, the travel, and the things we’re figuring out along the way. Now people are invested in the journey as well as the product. They celebrate our wins and encourage us through difficult moments because they’ve seen what went into them.

I wish we’d started sharing that side earlier. Giving people access has helped them feel part of the story, and their support has become a huge part of ours.

The Capitalyst: You’ve talked about food being both healing and indulgent, pushing back on the idea that wellness means restriction. Do you see that mindset shifting more broadly, or is Gato still swimming against the current?

Gabriella Gains: I do think it’s shifting. There are more brands taking ingredient quality seriously while also caring deeply about taste, which is exciting.

My own experience changed how I wanted to eat, but I don’t think a sweet treat needs to carry a promise of healing. What matters to me is making something delicious from ingredients we’re proud of, without turning enjoyment into a negotiation. I also find “better-for-you” a little vague. Better than what? I’d rather be specific about what’s in our product and let people decide how it fits into their lives.

At Gato, flavor comes first in how we introduce the brand. It’s what makes someone want another bite, come back for another pouch, and recommend us to a friend. But for our core date range, we won’t compromise our ingredient standards to achieve it. We know we can deliver both. Ultimately, I’d love to take some of the guilt out of indulgence. Eating something decadent should be a moment you enjoy, rather than something you feel you need to justify afterward.

The Capitalyst: Finding a compatible co-founder is notoriously difficult, yet you and Tonya are on your second venture together. What communication practices allow you to challenge each other while protecting your friendship and shared vision?

Gabriella Gains: The most important thing is remembering that we’re working toward the same goal. Tonya and I have a clear vision for Gato. When we disagree, we don’t approach the conversation as opponents trying to win. We’re two people trying to make the best decision for a company we both care deeply about.

That changes how you listen. If one of us challenges an idea, it doesn’t mean she isn’t supportive. It means she sees something worth discussing. We explain our reasoning, bring whatever information we have, and stay open to changing our minds. It also helps that we met as adults and came into this partnership with a strong understanding of ourselves. We know our strengths, how we work, and what matters to us outside the business.

We don’t have a complicated framework. We have a shared goal, respect for each other’s judgment, and a willingness to listen. Protecting the friendship means being able to have honest conversations, including the uncomfortable ones, without losing sight of the fact that we’re a team.

The Capitalyst: Looking ahead, what would success look like for Gato five years from now, commercially and culturally?

Gabriella Gains: Commercially, we want Gato in more people’s hands and more of the places they already spend time: grocery stores, cafés, hotels, and eventually airports and airlines. International growth matters to us personally, too. I was born in California but grew up in the UK, and Tonya was born and raised in Europe. Launching online in the UK has been special, and we’re excited to keep building beyond the US.

But success also means growing without losing what makes Gato feel like Gato. I admire brands like Fishwife for building such a distinctive identity around their category. We want that same strength of identity as our reach expands: premium ingredients, thoughtful design, and a product people feel excited to discover.

Culturally, I hope we help make indulgence feel more joyful and less restrictive. I want Gato to become a brand people reach for when they want to treat themselves or someone else. Our dates are the beginning. We have additional products planned, and the ambition is to bring that same point of view to more everyday rituals.

The Capitalyst: What does a typical week look like now, and how has your role changed since you were making the product in your kitchen?

Gabriella Gains: There are a lot more Zoom meetings and a lot more time spent living out of a suitcase. A typical week includes retailer conversations, content creation, collaboration planning, and whatever needs our attention operationally. We travel almost every month for events, trade shows, manufacturing visits, or time in our key markets.

At the beginning, our world was very local. We were focused on LA and could speak to customers face-to-face every weekend. Now we’re nationwide, so building those relationships takes more planning and travel. New York and Miami have become regular stops, and with production moving to Florida, we’ll be spending even more time there.

The biggest change is the scope of what we’re responsible for. We’re thinking about what the business needs today while also making decisions that will affect its next stage. But the team is still tiny. Tonya and I remain the only full-time employees, supported by fractional specialists. We’re still wearing a hundred hats. Growing the team is part of the plan. For now, it’s a very hands-on chapter and we’re involved in almost every part of building Gato.